Paperless Tiger
  • Paper[less] Tiger
  • BOOKS
  • COMING SOON
  • Press/Contact
  • Immersion Therapy
  • Curated Projects
  • Paper[less] Tiger
  • BOOKS
  • COMING SOON
  • Press/Contact
  • Immersion Therapy
  • Curated Projects

 paperlesstiger

A Tale As Old As Time - The Black Art Market

1/7/2015

0 Comments

 
It's a tale as old as time, right? You divide, you conquer and you then enjoy the spoils of your victories, dismantling existing culture to instate your own.
Sure, some cult like parts of your new community might never give up the goat, but for the most part, values and preferences change over time and power pays. Artists and artisans have to put bread on the table, so, they adapt to their new patrons. And in doing so, they unbeknowingly render their past creations collectibles.
In the past this kind of natural course of events was part of daily life. Materials that may have once been used to create places of cultural or religious significance were taken away and repurposed. You think this current trend with artists repurposing objects is a new thing? No way! It goes way back. Like that alcove on that temple? Great, take it home, make yourself a feature wall.  I insist! That stone does so much to keep out the heat in summer.
As time progressed and our values changed, a black market popped up, allowing the activity to be more monetized.  In the past this helped certain segments of the community profit from regime changes: people who found and offloaded the objects, the people who re-sold the objects, and eventually private collectors and institutions who didn't have to worry about provenance or pesky rules like they do in the modern age. Back then, they just needed to add breadth to their collections to build their reputations and importance...the blacker the market the better.
Picture
Schreitende Pferde' (pacing horses) by Austrian artist Josef Thorak - German police photos
Back then, the reselling of antiquities was often a way of guaranteeing that you had food on the table if you were fortunate enough to have inherited or found something through the course of your life.
But just as the market grew, so too did the daring of plunder. In particular, we can trace the current situation back to WWII when the plundering of objects reached a peak.
The appropriation of personal belongings and family heritage was one of the systematic devices of the Third Reich. The inequity and comprehensive nature of Hitler's approach to appropriating and reselling private property, particularly of Europe's Jewish population and of other opposing groups has had a lasting effect on the art world and is still creating consequences for modern institutions.
In the West, values have changed towards the illegal market. Most governments have police forces dedicated to countering this activity and the awareness and technology at hand has now forced the black art market further underground.
A growing awareness of provenance (where an artwork originated from, its history of ownership etc.) has made museums and galleries in particular ever more careful about their selections. Galleries and museums can't solely rely on a curator's research: these days for their own safety institutions have to rely more and more on legal teams to protect any potential investments.
That ISIS are reported to be involved in selling Iraqi (and more precisely, Assyrian) artifacts on the black market should come as no surprise.  On the one hand, collectors have a vested interest in guaranteeing that these objects come to no harm, and one might argue that selling these objects is a lesser evil than destroying them as we've all recently been witness to.
The surprising news that is emerging though is not related to ISIS' black market activities, but that rather there seems to be a market for Hitler related or Nazi sponsored art. And it's a huge multi million dollar market.
This market exists in addition parallel to the traditional market which initially seemed to help museums around the world build their collections (though that's now being re-addressed legally).
The issue here though is that there are people who are willing to part with big wads of cash to buy art that has, in some way, been sanctioned and supported by Hitler and his army. This suggests that it's not merely the art that is of interest to the collectors, but rather its association to the man.
Collectors won't  necessarily open their wallets simply because something is of aesthetic  value. Often their goal is to purchase work that will grow in value, and if we know anything about human nature, we know that value in art often corresponds to pivotal moments in cultural and political history. It's the event and not the aesthetic that often makes an art work highly prized (and valuable).
Lots of food for thought here. What does it say about us that there are people amongst us who, by and large are still supporting and basically lending a financial value to the atrocities committed by a man, his beliefs and his henchies?
If you're interested in looking in more detail at some of these issues then here are some good entry level articles:
ISIS and Iraqi artifacts here.
For simplicity, USA today's Hitler art article here.
How provenance impacts, particularly in new world museums like these two American ones. Here.

0 Comments

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Dave
    ​DI VITO

    ​Writer, teacher and former curator who splits his time between Rome and Melbourne.

    Picture
    Tweets by @DDVinyltiger
    Picture











    Picture
    Picture

    Subscribe!

    * indicates required

    Archives

    July 2022
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    February 2021
    April 2020
    July 2019
    March 2019
    August 2018
    March 2018
    August 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    November 2014
    October 2014
    March 2014
    July 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    November 2011
    September 2011
    August 2011
    July 2011
    June 2011
    May 2011
    April 2011
    June 2010
    May 2010
    April 2010

    Categories

    All
    2016
    80s Music
    Adelita Huang-Bey
    Ahmed Basiony
    Ai Weiwei
    Alec Soth
    Alessia Rollo
    Andris Eglitis
    Angelica Dass
    Ang Lee
    Anne Inhauf
    Art
    Art Curator
    Asako Narahashi
    Atif Khan
    Australia
    Bande A Sud
    Banksy
    Belinda Carlisle
    Berlin
    Bernardo Oyarzùn
    Beyonce
    Biennale 2011
    Biennale 2015
    Biennale 2017
    Biennale2019
    Biennale 2022
    Bill Viola
    Bitume
    Blonde Redhead
    Blondie
    Bruce Nauman
    Cabello/Carceller
    Candice Breitz
    Cevdet Erek
    Chiharu Shiota
    China
    Christo
    Cinthia Marcelle
    City
    Claudia Fontes
    Cody Choi
    Collin Sekajugo
    Contemporary Art
    Corporate Sponsorship
    Crash
    Crowdfunding
    Culture
    Curating
    Damon Kowarsky
    Dan Black
    Dapunta Hyang
    Darren Hayes
    David Bowie
    Design
    Diego Gualandris
    Donna Summer
    Dragoljub Raša Todosijevic
    Ekaterina Vasilyeva
    Elaine Sturtevant
    Electronica
    Environmental
    Events
    Exhibitions
    Fabrizio Albertini
    Fertility Day
    Fight The Fight
    Film
    Fiona Hall
    Flaka Haliti
    Francesc Ruiz
    Francis Alys
    Fuori
    Galleries
    Gal Weinstein
    George Drivas
    George Michael
    Gerald Machona
    Gian Maria Tosatti
    Giorgio Andreotta Calò
    Giorgio Di Noto
    GLBT
    Gloria Casto
    Great Tigers
    Gwen Stefani
    Gyula Vàrnai
    Hajnal Nemeth
    Hany Armanious
    Haruki Murakami
    Heri Dono
    Heritage Management
    Hiroshi Sugimoto
    Ibrahim Mahama
    If They Could Speak
    Illit Azoulay
    Imranovi
    Irma Blank
    Italian Pavilion
    Italy
    Ivan Grubanov
    Jana Źelibská
    Janet Jackson
    Jan Fabre
    Jan Stradtmann
    Japan
    Jason Moran
    Jeon Joonho
    Jesse Jones
    Joel Peter Witkin
    John Niven
    Jorge Fuembuena
    Jun Nakasuji
    Kaarina Kaikkonen
    Kanye West
    Kate Ceberano
    Katherine Macdaid
    Katrina Neiburga
    Keith Haring
    Kunstpedia
    Kutlug Ataman
    Kylie
    Kyoko Imazu
    Kyoto
    Land Art
    Last Train Home
    Laszlo Biro
    Latifa Echakhch
    Lebohang Kganye
    Lecce
    Lee Wan
    Lee Yongbaek
    Legambiente
    Lisa Reihana
    Lorenzo Maccotta
    Lucamaleonte
    Lushsux
    Madonna
    Making My Peace
    Makus Schinwald
    Marcello Maloberti
    Marco Fusinato
    Mark Jenkins
    Marzia Migliora
    Matthieu Bernard Raymond
    Maurizio Galimberti
    May You Live In Interesting Times
    Media
    Melbourne
    Meshell N
    M.i.a
    Michelangelo Pistoletto
    Mika Rottenberg
    Milk Of Dreams
    Mircea Cantor
    Modern Architecture
    Moha Modsiakeng
    Monica Bonvicini
    Moon Kyungwon
    Mounir Fatmi
    MTV
    Muhannad Shono
    Murals
    Museo Nazionale D'arte Orientale
    Museums
    Music
    Na Chainkua Reindorf
    Naples
    Natalie Imbruglia
    New Zealand
    Nicola Samori
    Nidhal Chamekh
    Nina's Drag Queens
    Nirvana
    Nufactory
    Painting
    Paris
    Pascale Marthine Tayou
    Pepo Salazar
    Pet Shop Boys
    Photography
    Pop
    Pop Culture
    Prince
    Printmakers
    Public Art
    Puglia
    Queendom
    Raffaela Naldi Rossano
    Ralph Rugoff
    Rania Matar
    Reactions
    Religion
    Retailing
    Riace
    Rihanna
    Rinko Kawauchi
    Rip
    Robbie Williams
    Roberto Cuoghi
    Robin Rhode
    Roisin Murphy
    Rome
    Salvador Dali
    Sam Harris
    Sculpture
    Self Publishing
    Shanghai
    Simone Leigh
    Social Media
    Space Invader
    Street Art
    Sun Kil Moon
    Super Pop
    Tabaimo
    Takahiro Iwasaki
    Television
    Terry Adkins
    Theatre
    Thomas Hirschhorn
    Tiago Mata Machado
    Tivoli
    Tomboys Don't Cry
    Tom Ford
    Tony Oursler
    Tori Amos
    Tracey Moffatt
    Travel
    Uffe Isolotto
    Unesco
    Vajiko Chachkhiani
    Valentina Vannicola
    Vatican Museum
    Venice
    Venice Biennale
    Vettor Pisani
    Video
    Video Art
    Vincent J Huang
    Vinyl Tiger
    Whitney Houston
    Willem Popelier
    Writing
    Wu Jian'an
    Wunderkammern
    Xu Bing
    Yao Huiffen
    Yuki Kihara
    Zai Kuning

    RSS Feed




Dave Di Vito is a writer, teacher and former curator.He's also the author of the Vinyl Tiger series and Replace The Sky.
For information about upcoming writing projects subscribe to the mailing list.
Dave hates SPAM so he won't trouble you with any of his own. He promises.